Report 2020-804 Recommendations
When an audit is completed and a report is issued, auditees must provide the State Auditor with information regarding their progress in implementing recommendations from our reports at three intervals from the release of the report: 60 days, six months, and one year. Additionally, Senate Bill 1452 (Chapter 452, Statutes of 2006), requires auditees who have not implemented recommendations after one year, to report to us and to the Legislature why they have not implemented them or to state when they intend to implement them. Below, is a listing of each recommendation the State Auditor made in the report referenced and a link to the most recent response from the auditee addressing their progress in implementing the recommendation and the State Auditor's assessment of auditee's response based on our review of the supporting documentation.
Recommendations in Report 2020-804: City of Lindsay: It Must Take Substantial Action to Address Its Financial Problems and Its Inadequate Management Practices (Release Date: August 2021)
| Recommendations to Lindsay, City of | ||
|---|---|---|
| Number | Recommendation | Status |
| 1 | To address the $6.3 million it improperly transferred to its general fund, Lindsay should, by February 2022, re-establish the loans to its restricted funds, and develop and implement a plan to fully repay those funds. |
Fully Implemented |
| 2 | To make prudent investments from federal funding to address its highest needs, Lindsay should develop a plan by November 2021 for how it will effectively use all American Rescue Plan funds. |
Fully Implemented |
| 3 | To ensure that its transfers of utility funds to the streets program comply with state law, Lindsay should perform a study to determine the appropriate level of funding from its utility fund for that program by August 2022 and update that study every three to five years. |
Pending |
| 4 | To ensure that it maintains adequate balances in its enterprise funds for significant purchases or capital expenditures, Lindsay should develop and implement a plan by June 2022 to build and maintain these balances. |
Partially Implemented |
| 5 | To ensure that the rates and fees it charges are appropriate to cover the cost of the related services, by August 2022 Lindsay should determine its cost to provide each of the services for which it charges a fee or rate and, as necessary, improve its accounting records to identify these costs. For any fees or rates that do not cover the costs of their related services, consider increasing those fees or rates, including a phased approach for large increases. For any fees or rates that are above the cost to provide the related service, consider reducing those fees or rates. |
Pending |
| 6 | To ensure that the rates and fees it charges are appropriate to cover the cost of the related services, by August 2022 Lindsay should improve its accounting records so as to identify how much revenue it receives from each fee or rate. |
Pending |
| 7 | Lindsay should adopt a policy for long-range financial planning by February 2022 that, at a minimum, identifies the forecast period for the plan, the funds it will include, efforts the city will make to increase revenues and decrease expenditures, and the frequency with which the finance director and the city manager will review the plan and propose any updates to the city council. |
Fully Implemented |
| 8 | City management should develop, and the city council should formally adopt, a long-term financial plan by August 2022 that aligns with best practices published by the GFOA. |
Fully Implemented |
| 9 | Lindsay should include in that financial plan a discussion of how it will reduce its pension and OPEB liabilities. As part of that plan, the city should consider requiring current employees to begin contributing to the future cost of their retirement health care benefits. |
Partially Implemented |
| 10 | To ensure that Lindsay's public safety model still meets the city's needs, Lindsay should evaluate the effectiveness of using a combined police and fire department by August 2022 and make any necessary changes. |
Fully Implemented |
| 11 | To ensure that Lindsay's public safety model still meets the city's needs, Lindsay should ensure that all public safety officers receive any necessary training within six months of employment beginning August 2022, including any public safety officers who are expected to respond to fires or emergencies. |
Partially Implemented |
| 12 | To ensure that its fire vehicles meet industry standards and its police vehicles are replaced in a timely manner, by November 2021 Lindsay should develop a sufficiently detailed public safety capital improvement plan that provides for the replacement of those vehicles. |
Fully Implemented |
